Video game remakes and remasters are becoming more common nowadays. While some offer the benefits of new hardware while preserving the charm of the original game, not all of them succeed. Whether it’s a complete overhaul or just a fresh coat of paint, the best remakes and remasters can provide a nostalgic experience for long-time fans or introduce newcomers to classic games. Let’s explore some retro video game remakes and remasters that have excelled, fallen short, or missed the mark entirely.
All-Time Great Remakes and Remasters
When done right, a good remake or remaster can enhance an already great game. Some remakes have even surpassed the originals in quality. From SNES classics to controversial shooters, these retro game remakes and remasters stand out among the rest.
1. Super Mario All-Stars (1993, Super Nintendo)
Super Mario All-Stars is a prime example of a well-executed retro video game remake. Featuring new art styles, updated visuals, and additional content, this collection of classic Super Mario games offers an enhanced experience for players. With the inclusion of games like Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels, this remake is a timeless gem that sets a high standard for future remakes.
2. Resident Evil (2002, GameCube)
The 2002 remake of Resident Evil is considered one of the best video game remakes ever made. With improved gameplay mechanics, updated visuals, and enhanced atmosphere, this remake sets a new standard for horror games. Even after two decades, this remake remains a masterpiece that surpasses the original in every aspect.
3. Doom + Doom II (2024, PC)
Nightdive Studios’ remastered compilation of Doom and Doom II showcases the best of these iconic first-person shooter titles. With updated graphics, new content, and online multiplayer support, this remaster elevates the classic Doom experience to new heights.
The Bad and the Ugly
While many remakes and remasters are successful, there are some that miss the mark entirely. Poorly made remakes can tarnish the legacy of the original games and disappoint fans. Let’s take a look at some examples of retro game remakes that failed to deliver.
1. Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy – The Definitive Edition (2021, PlayStation 5)
Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy – The Definitive Edition falls short of expectations with its poor visuals and numerous glitches. Despite promising modern updates, this remaster fails to capture the essence of the original games, resulting in a disappointing experience for fans.
2. Silent Hill HD Collection (2012, Xbox 360)
Silent Hill HD Collection suffers from inferior graphics and audio compared to the original games. The remaster fails to recreate the psychological horror and immersive atmosphere of the original titles, leading to a lackluster experience for players.
3. Warcraft III: Reforged (2020, PC)
Warcraft III: Reforged disappoints fans with its significant changes and removal of key features. This remaster fails to capture the magic of the original game, resulting in a lackluster experience for players. Blizzard’s mishandling of this beloved title serves as a cautionary tale for future remasters.
Related
Original article by www.oldschoolgamermagazine.com
